Research Methods

Validity and Reliability

Many students get a little muddled initially by these two concepts and so it may be helpful, at first, to suggest that they avoid using them in the same sentence. That is, try to avoid, “the study lacked reliability and validity”. Perhaps it did, but what is more likely is that it lacked one of these. Reliability can be thought of as repeatability – the extent to which, if you repeated the research, you would get the same results. Validity is whether you are measuring what you say you were measuring.

A good example of how to illustrate this in a lesson is using fabric tape measures (perhaps the ones you can find in that well-known Swedish furniture store!). Instruct students to work in pairs and to measure the circumference of each other’s head. Once they have made a note of this tell them that this is a measure of intelligence – the larger the head, the more intelligence. Clearly this is not the case and discussions will ensue. From this you can introduce the term validity – you are not measuring intelligence, you are measuring head size. Then ask them what will happen if they repeat the measurement (and get them to do this). The measurement will be the same, allowing for a small margin of change for positioning of the tape measure). The experiment has been repeated with the same results. So, there is high reliability but low validity.


 

More Resources from Discovering Sociology


Pressure Groups

Pressure groups play a key role in the political system. They tend..

Politics Teacher Resource

Absolutism

Absolutism is a political theory that suggests that power should b..

Politics Teacher Resource

Anarchism

The infamous ‘Anarchy in the UK’ by the Sex Pistols could be playi..

Politics Teacher Resource

Conservatism

A good overview of conservatism is provided by the Encyclopaedia B..

Politics Teacher Resource

Elite Theory

Elite theory is the notion that power is concentrated in the hands..

Politics Teacher Resource

Introduction to the Political System

A range of resources are available to help with an introductory se..

Politics Teacher Resource

Liberalism

Here students could be set the task of ‘teaching the teacher’ on l..

Politics Teacher Resource

Pluralism

Robert Dahl (1961) suggested that modern societies are characteris..

Politics Teacher Resource

Political Protest

Political protests have and do exist on a continuum from the peace..

Politics Teacher Resource

Socialism

The World Socialism organisation provides an account of ‘what soci..

Politics Teacher Resource